Ambivalence in Addiction: What If Part of Me Doesn't Want to Stop?
You can genuinely want to stop an addictive or compulsive behaviour while another part of you still wants what it provides. That conflict is called ambivalence, and it doesn't mean you aren't serious about change. Understanding both sides can help you make clearer decisions about what happens next, and therapy can help.
People sometimes come to therapy expecting me to ask whether they're ready to stop.
It's an understandable question, but the answer isn't always a straightforward yes or no.
You might desperately want to stop drinking but still look forward to the relief of the first drink. You might want to stop gambling while knowing you'll miss the excitement. You may hate what pornography, Findom, drugs, spending or another compulsive behaviour is doing to your life while still wanting something that happens when you engage with it.
Both things can be true.
That's ambivalence in addiction, and it's far more common than people sometimes realise.
It doesn't necessarily mean you're in denial, lack motivation or aren't taking the consequences seriously. It may simply mean the behaviour you're trying to change still has something to offer you.
Understanding that conflict can be far more useful than pretending it isn't there.
What Does Ambivalence in Addiction Actually Mean?
Ambivalence means experiencing conflicting feelings about something at the same time.
In addiction and compulsive behaviour, it often sounds something like:
"I want this to stop, but I don't want to give it up."
At first, that can seem contradictory. If a behaviour is damaging your finances, relationships, health or confidence, surely wanting to stop should be enough?
The difficulty is that we tend to look at the behaviour through the consequences it creates.
The person experiencing it also knows what happens before those consequences arrive.
Alcohol may provide relief. Gambling can create excitement and anticipation. Pornography might offer escape or sexual stimulation. Findom may involve connection, validation, submission or relief from responsibility. Spending can provide a temporary lift when everything else feels flat.
If we ignore those benefits, we only understand half of the argument taking place inside you.
If you're looking for useful resources rather than therapy click here
Wanting Change Doesn't Mean Wanting Everything About the Behaviour to Disappear
I've met plenty of people who are completely clear about what they want to lose.
They want the debt gone. They want the arguments to stop. They don't want to hide things anymore.
They want their concentration back, their relationship to improve or the anxiety about being discovered to disappear.
What they're less certain about is losing the part that worked.
Someone stopping alcohol may wonder how they'll relax without it. Someone reducing pornography may worry about losing a reliable form of sexual escape. A person stepping away from gambling might genuinely miss the excitement, even while being relieved that they're no longer losing money.
This is why simply listing the negative consequences doesn't always increase motivation.
The person probably already knows them.
The more useful conversation may be about what they believe they're giving up.
Sometimes You're Losing a Coping Strategy
When a behaviour has been part of someone's life for a long time, stopping can create a gap.
That gap may be practical. Friday evening used to mean going to the pub. Late at night meant pornography. Payday triggered gambling or spending.
But it can also be emotional.
If you've relied on something to change how you feel, what happens when it isn't there?
Stress is still stress. Loneliness doesn't disappear because you've stopped a behaviour. Neither do boredom, anxiety, rejection, anger or the need for excitement and connection.
This doesn't mean the behaviour is the only way of meeting those needs.
It does mean we shouldn't underestimate what we're asking somebody to give up.
Sometimes people need to develop alternatives before they feel completely ready to release the thing that has been doing that job.
The Behaviour Can Become Part of Who You Are
Not every conflict is about emotional regulation.
Sometimes a behaviour becomes connected with identity, relationships or belonging.
Drinking may have been part of your social life for decades. Sexual behaviour may connect with how you understand yourself sexually. Gambling might be something you've always shared with friends or family. Certain online communities can provide connection that isn't available elsewhere.
Changing the behaviour can therefore raise a bigger question:
Who am I without this?
That can sound dramatic until you're actually facing it.
If most of your friendships involve drinking, stopping alcohol isn't only about changing what is in your glass. If a sexual behaviour has occupied a large part of your private life, changing it can involve reconsidering how you understand your sexuality, relationships and needs.
Recovery sometimes involves discovering what remains when the behaviour takes up less space.
Pressure Can Make the Conflict Stronger
When other people can clearly see the harm, they understandably want change to happen quickly.
Partners want the pornography or sexual behaviour to stop. Families want someone to stop drinking or taking drugs. Financial problems create pressure to stop gambling or spending.
Sometimes immediate action really is necessary.
But pressure can also produce a situation where somebody starts arguing for change on the outside while privately arguing against it on the inside.
They say what everybody wants to hear.
"I'll never do it again."
"I've stopped."
"I know I need to change."
Meanwhile, the part that still wants the behaviour hasn't gone anywhere.
Shame can make this even harder. If admitting that you still want something feels unacceptable, it's much easier to hide that conflict than talk about it.
That doesn't resolve ambivalence.
It drives it underground.
My recent blog on secrecy and compulsive behaviour looks more closely at what can happen when parts of our behaviour become increasingly hidden.
Motivation Isn't an On/Off Switch
We sometimes talk about motivation as though you either have it or you don't.
Real life tends to be messier.
You can feel highly motivated on Monday morning and much less motivated on Friday night.
Motivation can change after an argument, during loneliness, when money arrives in your account or when you're suddenly presented with an opportunity to engage in the behaviour.
That doesn't make the motivation you felt earlier false.
It means motivation changes with circumstances.
For me, this is one reason recovery can't rely entirely on how motivated somebody happens to feel at a particular moment.
We can strengthen motivation, but we can also change routines, reduce opportunities, create accountability and build alternatives so that every decision doesn't depend on winning the same internal argument again.
Therapy Doesn't Need to Force a Decision
You don't have to arrive in therapy declaring that you're 100% committed to stopping forever.
In fact, I'd rather someone told me honestly:
"Part of me doesn't want to stop."
Now we have something useful to talk about.
What does that part want?
What is it frightened of losing?
What does it believe the behaviour provides?
And what does the part that wants change know about where things are heading?
Therapy can give both sides of that conversation some space without pretending that the consequences don't matter.
Understanding the reasons you want to continue isn't the same as encouraging you to continue.
It's about understanding the whole picture before deciding what needs to change.
If you're struggling specifically with alcohol or drug use, gambling, pornography, compulsive sexual behaviour or Findom, those individual patterns may need different practical responses even when the underlying ambivalence feels remarkably similar.
Moving Towards Change When You're Still Unsure
You don't need to resolve every bit of ambivalence before doing anything differently.
Start by being more specific about both sides.
Instead of writing a long list of reasons why you "should" stop, try asking what you genuinely want to change and what you genuinely don't want to lose.
You might notice that you don't actually want the behaviour itself as much as you want relief, excitement, connection, confidence or escape.
That distinction matters because it gives you more options.
You can also experiment rather than making enormous declarations. Change a routine. Introduce a delay. Reduce access. Tell somebody you trust what's happening. Try meeting the same need differently and notice what happens.
Then pay attention to the evidence.
Does life improve?
What do you miss?
What becomes easier?
What remains difficult?
Change can give you information that thinking about change never will.
You Don't Have to Pretend to Be Ready
If you're caught between wanting to stop and wanting to continue, you don't need to convince me that you're ready for change before getting in touch.
We can start with where you actually are.
If several behaviours are involved, my Short Cross Addiction Assessment may help you step back and look at patterns across different areas. It's a reflection and screening tool rather than a diagnosis.
For sexual behaviours, you can also use my Compulsive Sexual Behaviour Self-Assessment, Porn Use Self-Assessment or Findom Self-Assessment if one of those feels more relevant to what's happening.
Sometimes the first meaningful change isn't stopping the behaviour.
It's becoming honest about the fact that you're conflicted.
Once both sides are allowed into the conversation, we can begin understanding what each of them is trying to achieve and what would need to change for you to move forward without pretending that the decision was ever simple.
Taking the First Step
Taking the first step can feel difficult. If you're unsure whether therapy is right for you, we can arrange a free 15-minute consultation by phone.
There is no obligation to book therapy afterwards. It simply gives us an opportunity to discuss what is bringing you here, answer any questions you may have, and see whether we are a good fit to work together.
You can get in touch in whichever way suits you:
Comments